Access options available:. Journal of the History of Philosophy Curzer [P]unishment. We think young people should be prone to shame. Aristotle provides a partial description of the virtuous person in the following familiar passage.
|Published (Last):||25 January 2013|
|PDF File Size:||17.42 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||1.73 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Access options available:. Journal of the History of Philosophy Curzer [P]unishment. We think young people should be prone to shame.
Aristotle provides a partial description of the virtuous person in the following familiar passage. The virtuous person performing virtuous acts,. By my count, this passage lists five components of virtue. Presumably, the virtuous agent's knowledge consists in true beliefs concerning which acts are virtuous plus a correct account of why they are virtuous.
Virtue thus includes both 1 the ability to identify which acts are virtuous in a given situation and 2 an understanding of why they are virtuous. Choice is deliberate desire, so choosing virtuous acts is a combination of determining and desiring virtuous acts. People want to carry out virtuous acts for various reasons. For example, some choose virtuous acts merely because they are fashionable or instrumentally valuable.
But Aristotle specifies that the virtuous person 3 desires virtuous acts for their own sake. Finally, since a state of character includes dispositions to act and feel in certain ways, "a firm virtuous character" includes not only 4 dispositions of virtuous action, but also 5 dispositions of virtuous passion.
The virtuous person reliably acts and feels right. Since, "We are inquiring not in order to know what virtue is but in order to become good" b , it seems natural to ask how these five components of virtue are acquired. Aristotle's oft-repeated prescription for becoming virtuous [End Page ] is, "We become just by performing just acts, and temperate by performing temperate acts" a Now virtuous action is different in different situations, so habitually acting virtuously does not mean repeatedly doing the same thing, but rather it means repeatedly doing the right thing.
Nevertheless, it is easy enough to see how performing virtuous acts can provide dispositions of virtuous action. Aristotle explains elsewhere that teaching rather than habituation provides the explanation of why certain acts are virtuous b; see below.
Aristotle suggests that dispositions of virtuous passion are inculcated through music Politics ab How do we acquire the ability to identify virtuous acts? How do we come to desire virtuous acts for their own sake?
In a classic article entitled "Aristotle on Learning to be Good," Myles Burnyeat presents answers to these two questions. So according to Burnyeat, Aristotle thinks that guided habituation enables you acquire the ability to judge for yourself which acts are virtuous. To begin with, you need "someone around to tell you what is noble and just. But you do not become a good judge of Project MUSE promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide.
You need a good upbringing not simply in order that you may have someone around to tell you what is noble and just--you do need that. Aristotle discusses whether the job is best done by one's father or by community arrangements--but you need also to be guided in your conduct so that by doing the things you are told are noble and just you will discover that what you have been told is true.
Additional Information. Project MUSE Mission Project MUSE promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide.
Eliot Prose. Contact Contact Us Help.
Aristotle on learning to be good
Howard J. ABSTRACT: Aristotle says that we learn which acts are virtuous, choose virtuous acts for their own sake, and acquire virtuous habits by performing virtuous acts. According to Burnyeat, Aristotle thinks this works successfully because virtuous acts are pleasant. Instead, I maintain that according to Aristotle moral progress is motivated by different sorts of pain associated with vicious acts.